The Supplement Shake-Up of 2026: What You’re Swallowing Might Be Useless (or Worse)

The Supplement Shake-Up of 2026: What You’re Swallowing Might Be Useless (or Worse)

Stop Swallowing Hype

TLDR: Most supplements are a joke, fueled by the marketing machine and social media influencers.

Spider Chalk makes the world's best climbing chalk, gym chalk blocks, and longest-lasting liquid chalk (we also make "clear chalk" called Ghost Grip). We have a team of real athletes that train nonstop, year-round, and test supplements and gear.

If your kitchen counter looks like a pharmacy married a smoothie bar, this one’s for you. The supplement aisle went full “shiny object” in 2025—glossy claims, micro-doses, and enough buzzwords to power a Peloton class. The Spider Chalk team (3 guys, 2 girls) tested a pile of popular products, read the labels no one wants to read, and here’s our honest review—fast, punchy, and BS-free (and why steak is better than ALL supplements).

The 10-Second Take

Most people overpay for:

  • Underdosed blends that can’t deliver the headline promise

  • Proprietary formulas hiding exactly how little you’re getting

  • Stack conflicts (creatine + whey protein + pre-workout = 🚨)

Meanwhile, a tiny handful of boring, proven staples still do the heavy lifting. Our team tested them side-by-side and the results were…predictably unsexy.

What We Actually Did (no lab coats, real life)

  • Label autopsies: We weighed capsules, checked serving sizes vs. research-backed ranges.

  • Taste/mix trials: Protein, greens, and electrolytes across shakes and water—because compliance dies with bad flavors.

  • Before/after comparisons: Four weeks per product category to see if anything budged: sleep quality, HRV, training volume, perceived energy.

  • Price per effective dose: Because “$29.99 for 30 days” means nothing if you need 3 scoops to hit a real dose.

Our honest review: Most “wow” claims faded after week two. The quiet winners were the usual suspects.

Red Flags That Screamed “Skip Me”

  • Proprietary blend with heroic names (e.g., “Thermo Maxx Matrix”) and fake ingredient amounts

  • Sprinkle dosing: trendy ingredients at novelty levels (e.g., 25 mg when studies used 300–600 mg)

  • Hidden stimulants: multiple caffeine sources + yohimbe-ish add-ons = jitter party

  • Fat-soluble megadoses: A, D, E, K without a deficiency or plan—easy to overdo

  • Detox/cleanse promises: Your liver already is the detox. Nourish it; don’t harass it.

Categories We’d Rethink (Because our team tested and yawned)

  • “Test boosters” & “metabolism igniters”: spicy labels, sleepy outcomes.

  • Greens as multivitamins: helpful as a produce nudge, not a health insurance policy.

  • Nootropic party mixes: noticeable day one (stims), meh by week two (tolerance).

  • “Immune support” and "Creatine" gummies: mostly sugar with a side of marketing.

Categories That Still Pull Their Weight (the boring truth)

  • Protein powder (whey or casein, avoid pea/rice or other weirdo frankenfoods): Convenient protein is still the king. Our team only uses whey protein isolate from grassfed cows with zero artificial sweeteners like Acesulfame Potassium, Sucralose, etc. Choose stevia options or unflavored.

  • Creatine monohydrate: Cheap, studied, effective for strength, power, and maybe cognition. 3–5 g daily. Our honest review: noticeable training volume bump in 2–3 weeks. Which is best? See our "Comparison of 3 types of creatine" post.

  • Electrolytes without the candy: If you sweat like a human sprinkler or train in heat, a low-sugar mix helped cramping and “I’m cooked” moments. We prefer the Redmonds Re-Lyte which is based on Redmonds salt.

  • Vitamin D: Direct sun is better but some of you live in the North.

  • Caffeine (respectfully): Coffee or tea—watch your total daily intake.

The “Minimalist Stack” Our Team Keeps Using

  • AM/Pre-workout: Coffee ~60–100 mg caffeine (max), optional electrolytes

  • Post-workout: 25–35 g protein shake if your meal is >2 hours away

  • Daily: 3–5 g creatine monohydrate (whenever—timing isn’t precious)

  • Conditional: Vitamin D only if you’re actually deficient

Our team tested this for six weeks across lifters, runners, and hybrid athletes. Biggest wins: better training consistency, fewer sore days, and a calmer stomach.

How to Read a Label in 20 Seconds

  • Dose vs. research range: If the label dodges amounts, that’s your answer.

  • Stims per serving: Count total caffeine, don't add more when you're tired.

  • Third-party testing: Look for NSF/USP/Informed Choice. Avoid anything from China.

  • Per-effective-dose price: Cost ÷ scoops needed to hit real dosing. Sneaky expensive is still expensive.

“But I Feel It!” Placebo vs. Progress

You should feel some things (alertness from caffeine, fewer cramps with enough sodium, incremental strength with creatine).
You shouldn’t need:

  • A second mortgage

  • Three different “fat burners”

  • Four gummies before bed “for sleep” (fix your routine first)

Our honest review: Feeling wired ≠ making progress. We care about recovery, volume, and measurable work—placebo can’t fake heavier sets for long.

Common Stacking Mistakes (we made them, so you don’t)

  • Double-dosing stims: Coffee + “focus caps” + pre-workout = 🚫 sleep, 🚫 recovery.

  • Greens + multi + fortified drinks: Accidental megadosing, especially fat-solubles.

  • “Natural” ≠ safe: Plant extracts can still mess with meds.

  • Weekend warrior dosing: Supplements aren’t cheat codes for inconsistency.

A 2-Week Reset if Your Stack Got Out of Hand

Week 1:

  • Strip back to protein + creatine + electrolytes.

  • Track sleep and training (volume, RPE, mood).

Week 2:

  • Add back one variable if you truly missed an effect (e.g., moderate caffeine pre-workout).

  • Keep a simple log. If it’s not measurable, it’s marketing.

Our team cycled since the body adapts very quickly.

FAQ 

Do I need a multivitamin?
No if you're eating red meat, yes if you are a veggie-loving vegan. 

Best time for creatine?
Never at night, always before noon. Daily consistency > timing.

Are greens powders worth it?
No. Total junk.

Pre-workout or coffee?
Coffee or tea. If sleep stinks or anxiety spikes, dial it down.

The Bottom Line

Supplements are mostly expensive marketing hype. Eating a steak 3-4x a week will give you more benefits than the perfect $80/month stack. Ever notice how the "perfect stack" changes every 2-3 years depending on what is trending on social media? And yet everyone is still fat, weak, and rarely making gains?

Our honest review: save your cash for red meat.

Back to blog