Comparing the Benefits and Effectiveness of 3 Types of Creatine

Comparing the Benefits and Effectiveness of 3 Types of Creatine

Spider Chalk makes the world's best chalk. Our team of athletes regularly competes in weightlifting, powerlifting, and CrossFit, and we occasionally test new products and offer honest reviews.

Comparing the Benefits and Effectiveness of 3 Types of Creatine

What We’ll Cover

  • What are the most common types of creatine

  • How they differ in strength gains, muscle growth, side effects, and cost

  • Which type might be best for you, depending on goals like performance, budget, or digestion

Why It’s Important to Choose the Right Creatine

Creatine is easily one of the most studied and reliable performance supplements. But not all creatine is the same. Differences in formulation, bioavailability, and cost make a real impact. Choosing the wrong type can lead to bloating, digestive issues, or just wasted money. Choose a brand made in the USA for optimal quality, even if it costs a couple more bucks.

Creatine Types We Tested

We tested three popular forms of creatine over several months to compare:

Type What It Is Typical Dose Used
Creatine Monohydrate The “standard” form; very well researched 5 g/day
Creatine HCL (Hydrochloride) Monohydrate chemically bonded with HCl; claims to dissolve better and need lower doses ~750 mg to 1.5 g/day
Kre-Akalyn Buffered creatine; touted for having fewer stomach issues ~1.5 g/day

 

How They Compare: Pros & Cons

Creatine Monohydrate

Pros:

  • Strong, consistent strength gains (e.g. lifting more over time)

  • Significant muscle size gains

  • Most research support

  • Cost-effective when bought in bulk

Cons:

  • Larger serving size (generally 5 g/day)

  • Can cause bloating or stomach discomfort for some users

  • Some “micronized” or “fast dissolving” variants make claims that are not always backed by data

Best For: Someone who wants maximum results, doesn’t mind taking a slightly larger scoop, and can tolerate a bit of water retention.

Creatine HCL

Pros:

  • Smaller serving sizes are easier for some to take

  • Less likely to cause bloating or digestive issues

  • Still delivers decent strength and muscle growth (especially at higher doses)

Cons:

  • Higher cost per gram compared to monohydrate

  • Gains are generally somewhat less dramatic than monohydrate at equivalent weight/day (assuming dosing is lower)

  • Sometimes harder to find high-quality products

Best For: Users sensitive to digestion issues, or people wanting a smaller dose but still seeking results.

Kre-Akalyn

Pros:

  • Least likely to cause stomach upset or bloating

  • Small doses, easy on the stomach

  • More affordable than some HCL options

Cons:

  • Strength and size gains tend to lag behind monohydrate and HCL (in our tests)

  • Less scientific data overall

  • May be harder to find good brands

Best For: Users who have tolerate monohydrate poorly, or want something gentler and still effective.

Our Hack: Combining Monohydrate + HCL

From our testing: mixing ≈2 g monohydrate + 750 mg HCL per day gave us the strength and size gains of monohydrate without the bloating or digestive discomfort commonly reported with the full 5 g monohydrate alone. If you can find quality sources, this combo is the BEST.

How to Choose the Right Creatine for You

Here are some criteria to help you pick:

  1. Goal

    • Strength + size at max → go monohydrate

    • Size with less side effects → HCL or combo

    • Mild digestion, minimal side effects → Kre-Akalyn or smaller doses

  2. Budget

    • Monohydrate is often the most affordable per effective gram

    • HCL and Kre-Akalyn usually cost more when you scale up

  3. Tolerance / Digestion

    • If you’re prone to stomach upset, start with HCL or Kre-Akalyn

    • Try smaller doses first before moving up

  4. Quality / Brand

    • Look for third-party tested, Made in the USA brands

    • Avoid vague sourcing, claims like “micronized” or “fast-absorbing” without evidence

Frequently Asked Questions (SEO + Users Love These)

  • Does creatine monohydrate cause more bloating than other types?
    Yes, often—but that bloating tends to be water retention and may lessen over time. Using smaller doses or combining with HCL can help.

  • Is HCL really more bioavailable?
    Some claims say yes. In our tests, HCL seemed easier on digestion, but strength & muscle gains weren’t drastically superior to monohydrate when dosed correctly.

  • Can beginners benefit more from monohydrate because of the research behind it?
    Absolutely. Monohydrate has more robust support in studies, making it a safer “default” choice for new users.

  • How long until I should see results?
    Usually within 3-4 weeks for strength improvements, and noticeable muscle fullness after consistent use (4-8 weeks) when paired with good training and nutrition.

Final Take

If you want maximum bang for your buck: monohydrate still wins.
If you need gentler effects on digestion or smaller doses: go with HCL or Kre-Akalyn.
The combo of monohydrate + HCL might offer the best of both worlds—strong gains and fewer negative side effects.

Above all: pick a high-quality brand, start with moderate doses, track results, and adjust based on how your body responds.

Back to blog